Finding the Best Platform to Sell Online

Choosing the best platform to sell online really boils down to what you want to achieve. If you're just starting out and your main goal is to get up and running quickly with minimal fuss, an all-in-one solution like Shopify is often the best bet. But if you're someone who craves complete creative freedom and wants to tweak every little detail, you’ll feel more at home with an open-source platform like WooCommerce.

Understanding Your E-commerce Foundation

Picking where you build your online store is arguably the most foundational decision you'll make. It’s a choice that will ripple through every aspect of your business, from your day-to-day operations and marketing efforts to your ability to grow down the road. The decision really boils down to two core models: hosted or self-hosted platforms.

Hosted platforms, also known as Software-as-a-Service (SaaS), take care of all the technical headaches for you. For a monthly fee, they manage security, software updates, and hosting. This approach is all about convenience, making it perfect for entrepreneurs who want to focus on their products and customers, not on website maintenance.

Self-hosted platforms like WooCommerce, on the other hand, give you the software for free, but you're in charge of finding and paying for your own web hosting. This path gives you total ownership and virtually limitless flexibility to create a one-of-a-kind store. Think of it as owning the building versus renting a spot in a mall.

The global e-commerce platform market was valued at around USD 9.40 billion in 2024 and is expected to soar to USD 45.60 billion by 2033. This incredible growth shows just how critical these online selling tools have become.

Making this initial choice will help narrow down your options and set you up for a much clearer comparison later. To dive deeper into building a solid foundation, check out our guide on creating an effective e-commerce strategy here: https://ecommerce.co/

The right platform isn't just a tool; it's a business partner. Your choice should align with your technical comfort, budget, and long-term vision for growth, not just your immediate needs.

Platform Comparison at a Glance

This table offers a quick summary of the top contenders, highlighting their core strengths and ideal user profiles to help you quickly identify which platforms align with your business needs.

Ultimately, this first decision between a hosted or self-hosted solution is the most important fork in the road. Getting this right will make every subsequent step in building your online business feel much more natural and aligned with your goals.

A Closer Look at All-in-One Hosted Platforms

When you're starting out, platforms like Shopify and BigCommerce feel like a godsend. They're often the first place new entrepreneurs land when they want to start selling online, and for good reason. The whole idea is to make your life easier. For a flat monthly fee, they take care of all the tech headaches—hosting, security, keeping things updated—so you can just focus on what you're good at: your products and your customers.

Think of them as the perfect digital landlord. You're renting a secure, ready-to-go retail space that comes with slick design templates and a dashboard that actually makes sense. You can go from zero to a professional-looking, fully functioning store in a few hours, not weeks. That speed is a massive advantage when you just want to get your product out there and see if people will buy it.

But, like any rental, this convenience comes with a few ground rules. You're building your business inside their ecosystem, which means you're trading a bit of creative freedom and control for that simplicity. You can definitely customize your store, but you have to work within the walls they've built.

The Real Price of "Plug-and-Play"

On the surface, the pricing seems simple. You see a number like Shopify’s $29 per month basic plan and think, "I can do that." But that monthly fee is just the starting point. The total cost of running your store is a different story, and the devil is in the details—specifically, the transaction fees.

This is a big one. Many hosted platforms, with Shopify being the most famous example, will charge you an extra percentage on every single sale if you don’t use their in-house payment processor. These fees, which can be anywhere from 0.5% to 2% of the sale price, start to really sting as your sales climb. It's a small slice, but it's a slice from every single transaction. It’s worth noting that BigCommerce stands out here by charging zero transaction fees, a detail that often gets lost in the noise but can make a huge difference to your bottom line.

The sticker price of a hosted platform is just the entry ticket. The real cost emerges from a combination of monthly fees, transaction percentages, and the app subscriptions you'll inevitably need.

And don't forget the tier system. The features you really need to grow—like abandoned cart recovery, better reporting, or lower credit card rates—are almost always reserved for the more expensive plans. It’s their way of making sure the platform grows with you, but it also guarantees your monthly bill will climb right alongside your success.

The App Marketplace: A Blessing and a Curse

One of the best things about Shopify and BigCommerce is their massive app marketplaces. Want to add a customer loyalty program? Need more powerful SEO tools? How about setting up product subscriptions? Yep, there’s an app for that. This ecosystem lets you bolt on some seriously powerful features without knowing a lick of code.

This plug-and-play approach is fantastic for getting new functionality up and running quickly. The catch? You have to pay for the good stuff. Many of the best, most essential apps come with their own monthly subscriptions. Before you know it, a handful of "must-have" apps can easily add another $50-$150 (or more) to your monthly expenses.

There’s another hidden cost, too. Every app you install adds more code to your website, which can sometimes slow down your page load speeds or, even worse, conflict with other apps you have installed. While the core platform is managed for you, you're suddenly in the business of managing app compatibility and performance, which is a maintenance headache most merchants don't see coming.

Customization and Scaling: Where They Differ

People often assume all hosted platforms are rigid, but the level of flexibility you get can vary quite a bit. Knowing the subtle differences is what will help you pick the right home for your brand.

So, what does this mean for you? If your business sells products with tons of variations and custom options, you might find that BigCommerce's built-in tools get you there faster and cheaper. But if your brand is all about a polished look and a beautiful customer experience, you might lean toward Shopify’s incredible theme selection and design-focused apps, even if it costs a bit more in subscriptions. It all comes down to where you want to focus your energy and your budget.

Tapping into Open-Source Freedom

For businesses that refuse to be boxed in by templates, open-source platforms are the ultimate expression of creative freedom. Instead of just renting space in a pre-built system, you get the actual blueprints. You can build your store exactly the way you want it, with no rules but your own. This is the heart of what makes platforms like WooCommerce, which is built on the world's most popular content management system, WordPress, so appealing.

This approach gives you total control over every pixel, every feature, and every line of code. It's the perfect path for brands that need a deeply customized shopping experience—the kind a hosted platform just can't deliver. But with that power comes a lot more responsibility. You're not just the shop owner; you're also the architect, builder, and maintenance crew.

Choosing an open-source solution isn't about finding the best platform to sell online. It's about building it yourself from a powerful, flexible foundation. It definitely requires a more hands-on approach, but the reward is a store that is truly, uniquely yours.

The Real Cost of "Free"

That word "free" is tempting, isn't it? But when it comes to open-source software, you have to think about the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO). While the WooCommerce plugin itself doesn't cost a dime to download, running a professional, secure, and fast online store involves several critical expenses that are normally bundled into the monthly fees of hosted solutions.

Here’s a good way to think about it: hosted platforms are like an all-inclusive resort, while open-source is like buying a plot of land to build your own house. The land might be cheap or even free, but you’re still on the hook for materials, utilities, and security.

These necessary costs usually include:

• Web Hosting: This is the digital real estate your store is built on. Quality e-commerce hosting can run anywhere from $15 to $100+ per month, depending on your traffic and security needs.

• Domain Name: Your store’s address on the internet, which typically costs about $15 per year.

• Security (SSL Certificate): While many hosts include this, ensuring your checkout is secure is non-negotiable and can sometimes be an extra cost.

• Premium Extensions: To get the same advanced features you'd find in Shopify or BigCommerce, you'll need to buy premium plugins for things like subscriptions, advanced shipping, or specific payment gateways. These can range from $50 to $250+ each.

The upside to this model is that you control your spending. You only pay for the exact features you need instead of a bloated plan full of tools you'll never touch.

When Does WooCommerce Make the Most Sense?

The hands-on nature of open-source isn't for everyone. But for certain kinds of businesses, that flexibility isn't just an advantage—it's essential. This is where a platform like WooCommerce really pulls ahead of the competition.

Its market position says a lot. Globally, WooCommerce holds the largest e-commerce platform market share at 20.1%, proving just how popular it is for those who need to customize. It's followed by custom-built solutions and then Shopify, which powers millions of sites and has a major foothold in the U.S., especially with high-traffic stores. For a deeper dive, you can read more about these e-commerce platform statistics to see the full market breakdown.

So, when is open-source the clear winner? Here are a few real-world scenarios:

1. Content-Heavy Brands If your business depends on blogging, publishing tutorials, or using rich content to attract customers, nothing beats the combination of WordPress and WooCommerce. You can create complex article layouts and weave your products seamlessly into your content in ways that are clunky or impossible on platforms where the blog feels like an afterthought.

2. Stores with Complex Product Options Imagine you sell custom-built furniture where customers pick the wood, the finish, and the hardware. On a hosted platform, you'd be stuck trying to make expensive, and often clunky, apps work. With WooCommerce, a developer can build a product configurator right into your site, making the experience feel completely natural for the user.

3. Businesses with Niche International Needs For merchants selling across multiple countries with different tax laws, shipping rules, and payment gateways, WooCommerce offers unmatched control. You can install specific extensions or develop custom code to handle unique logistical challenges without being handcuffed by a platform's built-in limitations.

The decision to go open-source with a platform like WooCommerce is a strategic one. It's an investment in long-term flexibility, true ownership, and the ability to create a competitive advantage through a completely custom user experience.

Ultimately, choosing the open-source path means trading plug-and-play simplicity for limitless potential. If your business has unique needs and you're comfortable managing the technical side of things, it offers the most powerful and scalable foundation you can get.

Selling on Online Marketplaces

Making the move from your own storefront to a major online marketplace is a bit like swapping a standalone boutique for a stall in a massive, sprawling shopping mall. Platforms like Amazon, Etsy, and eBay offer one thing that’s almost impossible to resist: a huge, built-in audience of people ready to buy. For a new business, that can feel like the ultimate shortcut.

Instead of pouring months and a ton of cash into marketing just to find your first few customers, you can list a product and get it in front of millions of people, sometimes overnight. This immediate exposure is fantastic for market validation. You get to test out new product ideas, play with pricing, and see what people actually want before you go all-in on building your own branded website.

But all that convenience and traffic comes with some serious strings attached. You’re essentially just renting space in someone else’s empire. That means you have to play by their rules, pay their fees, and go head-to-head with thousands of other sellers all under the same digital roof.

The True Cost of a Built-In Audience

The first thing you'll notice about selling on marketplaces is the cost. These platforms are businesses, after all, and they take a healthy slice of every single sale. The fee structures can get complicated, often mixing together listing fees, transaction fees, payment processing fees, and the cost of advertising.

• Listing Fees: This is the small charge you pay just to get your product up on the site.

• Transaction/Referral Fees: This is the big one. It’s a percentage of the total sale price (including shipping) that can range anywhere from 5% to over 20%, depending on the platform and what you’re selling.

• Advertising Costs: The competition on these platforms is so fierce that you often have to pay for advertising just to get your products seen. This adds yet another layer to your customer acquisition costs.

These fees can eat into your profit margins in a hurry, especially if you're selling lower-priced items. What looks like a simple way to sell can quickly turn into a tricky financial balancing act, where you’re constantly fighting to stay profitable as the platform's costs creep up.

Amazon vs. Etsy: A Tale of Two Ecosystems

It's crucial to remember that not all marketplaces are the same. Each one is built for different kinds of sellers and products, so picking the right one is a major strategic decision.

Let's look at Amazon and Etsy. They're both giants, but they operate in completely different worlds.

Think about it this way: a business selling standard phone cases would probably do well with Amazon's massive audience and FBA logistics. On the other hand, an artist selling custom-engraved jewelry would feel much more at home in Etsy's community, where shoppers value uniqueness far more than two-day shipping.

The Battle for Brand Control

Perhaps the biggest long-term risk of relying only on marketplaces is the loss of your brand identity and your connection to your customers. You're building your business on someone else's property.

In the United States, Amazon is the undisputed king, controlling a staggering 37.6% of all online sales. With that kind of power, they get to control the entire customer experience, leaving you with very little space to build a direct relationship. You can dig deeper into the state of e-commerce market share to really grasp the scale of these platforms.

When you sell on a marketplace, you’re often just another listing, not a distinct brand. The customer's loyalty is to Amazon or Etsy, not to you. That makes it incredibly difficult to build a sustainable business with loyal, repeat customers.

In the end, while marketplaces are an amazing tool for getting those first sales and proving your ideas, the most successful brands see them as just one part of a bigger strategy. The real goal is often to use their traffic to eventually bring customers back to a platform you actually own—where you control the brand, own the customer data, and get to keep a much bigger piece of the pie.

Comparing Critical Features for Growth

Choosing the best platform to sell online isn't just about a pretty storefront. It’s about picking a partner with the right toolkit to fuel your growth for years to come. The features that seem small at first—things like payment processing, inventory management, and analytics—quickly become the engine of your daily operations. How a platform handles these essentials can either launch you forward or become a constant source of frustration.

Let's get into a head-to-head comparison of how Shopify, WooCommerce, and BigCommerce stack up in the areas that truly matter. By understanding their different philosophies, you'll see which ecosystem is genuinely built to support your specific business goals.

Payment Processing Flexibility and Costs

How you get paid directly hits your bottom line and shapes your customer's checkout experience. Each platform approaches this differently, which can mean big swings in what you actually pay per transaction.

Shopify really pushes you toward its own Shopify Payments, an integrated solution powered by Stripe. It's incredibly simple to get going and offers decent credit card rates that get better as you upgrade your plan. But here's the catch: if you need to use an external gateway like PayPal or Authorize.net, Shopify will charge you an additional transaction fee of up to 2% on every single sale. That's a huge deal for businesses that have specific processor needs.

BigCommerce takes a more hands-off approach. It works with over 65 payment gateways right out of the box and, crucially, charges zero additional transaction fees no matter which one you use. This freedom can mean real, substantial savings, especially as your sales volume climbs.

Then there's WooCommerce, which gives you total freedom. Since it's open-source, it can connect with practically any payment gateway that has a WordPress plugin. You’re only responsible for the standard fees your processor charges (like Stripe or PayPal), with no extra cuts going to the platform. This gives you absolute control over your payment setup.

The real cost of taking a payment isn't just the credit card rate. It's that rate plus any extra fees the platform tacks on. For a lot of businesses, BigCommerce's zero-fee policy ends up being more predictable and often cheaper than Shopify's model.

This visual breakdown really drives home the pricing differences, showing how those monthly fees and transaction costs add up.

As the chart makes clear, a low entry price doesn't tell the whole story. Transaction fees can drastically change your total costs as your business starts to take off.

Core Feature Showdown Shopify vs WooCommerce vs BigCommerce

A detailed comparison of essential e-commerce features across the top platforms, helping you match platform capabilities to your specific operational needs.

This table cuts through the noise, showing you where each platform really shines. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize simplicity (Shopify), total control (WooCommerce), or built-in power (BigCommerce).

Inventory Management for Simple and Complex Catalogs

Nothing kills momentum like stockouts and overselling. The right inventory system depends entirely on how complex your product catalog is.

Shopify gives you excellent, easy-to-use inventory tools that are perfect if your product line is fairly straightforward. It handles stock tracking, automates updates, and gives you basic reports. But if you need to manage product bundles or sync inventory across multiple warehouses, you’ll be heading straight to its massive app marketplace.

BigCommerce, on the other hand, really excels here, with more powerful inventory features baked right in. It has strong native options for handling product variations (SKUs), tracking stock with precision, and setting up bulk pricing rules—all without needing to install a third-party app. This makes it a much stronger contender for merchants with large or complicated catalogs from the get-go.

WooCommerce starts as a blank slate. Its built-in inventory tools are just the basics. The real power comes from its ecosystem of extensions. With the right plugins, you can build a highly sophisticated system tailored to any need, whether that's managing perishable goods or syncing with a massive ERP system.

Native SEO and Site Performance

How easily customers find you on Google often comes down to your platform's technical SEO toolkit.

• Shopify offers solid, user-friendly SEO tools. You can easily edit title tags, meta descriptions, and image alt text. The big limitation? It enforces a rigid URL structure (like /collections/ and /products/) that you have no power to change, which can be a real headache for advanced SEO strategies.

• BigCommerce gives you more advanced SEO settings right away. You get full control over your URL structures, can edit your robots.txt file directly, and benefit from handy features like automatic image optimization that help your site load faster.

• WooCommerce, being built on WordPress, gives you unparalleled SEO control. With legendary plugins like Yoast SEO or Rank Math, you can fine-tune every single technical aspect of your site—from schema markup to sitemaps—giving you the most potential to climb the search rankings.

Actionable Analytics and Reporting

Making smart, data-driven decisions is how you scale an e-commerce business. Each platform serves up a different level of insight. Shopify’s dashboard is famously clean, offering clear reports on sales, customers, and marketing. BigCommerce provides more granular, store-level analytics from day one. WooCommerce's reporting is pretty basic, but it connects beautifully with Google Analytics and a universe of powerful WordPress plugins for deep, custom insights.

For a closer look at what to expect from various plans, you can check out our detailed guide on https://ecommerce.co/pricing.

How to Make Your Final Decision

Picking the right platform is a big deal, but you don't need to get paralyzed by the options. At the end of the day, the best place to sell your products online is the one that just fits—it fits your business model, your comfort level with tech, and your plans for the future.

Let’s cut through the noise and break it down into a few common scenarios. Think of this as a gut check. Be honest about where you are right now and where you want to go, and the right choice will become much clearer.

Recommendations for Your Business Profile

Your current business stage is probably the biggest clue to which platform will feel like a partner rather than a problem. See which of these profiles sounds most like you.

• For the Solo Entrepreneur or Dropshipper If you just need to get up and running fast with minimal fuss, a hosted, all-in-one solution is your ticket. A platform like Shopify is built for this. You can realistically have a professional-looking store live in a weekend because they handle all the security and hosting headaches. This leaves you free to pour all your energy into what actually matters: marketing and making sales.

• For the Established Retailer Moving Online If you're already running a brick-and-mortar store with a large inventory and established ways of doing things, you'll want something with more muscle out of the box. This is where BigCommerce shines. It’s designed to handle complex product catalogs and manage sales across different channels without making you pay for a dozen different apps just to get basic functionality. It's a solid, scalable foundation.

• For the Content Creator or Brand Builder If your business is built around your content—a popular blog, a series of tutorials, or a tight-knit community—then WooCommerce on WordPress is practically a no-brainer. Nothing else gives you that level of control to weave your shop directly into your content. It offers unparalleled flexibility to build a truly unique brand experience that your audience will love.

Your platform choice is a long-term partnership. Select the one that not only solves today's problems but also has the features and flexibility to support your vision for the next three to five years.

Frequently Asked Questions

Diving into the world of e-commerce brings up a lot of questions, especially when you're trying to pick the right place to sell your products online. Getting straight answers is the first step to building your store with confidence. Let's tackle a few of the most common things people ask.

We'll cover everything from what it costs to get started to thinking about your long-term business plan, making sure you have what you need to make a smart choice.

Which Platform Is Cheapest to Start?

It’s easy to get lured in by "free" open-source software like WooCommerce, but the real cost isn't always obvious. While the software itself is free, you still have to pay for hosting, security certificates, and often a handful of premium plugins to get the functionality you actually need. Those costs can add up fast.

For someone just starting out who wants a simple, predictable monthly bill, a platform like Shopify is often the most budget-friendly way to get off the ground. Their basic plans roll everything—including secure hosting—into one manageable fee, which takes a lot of the guesswork out of your initial expenses.

Can You Switch Platforms Later?

The short answer is yes, but it's rarely a walk in the park. Moving your store from one platform to another is a highly technical job. You have to export all your product data, customer lists, and past order information and then very carefully import it into the new system.

While there are migration tools and specialized services that can help, it's a major undertaking that can cause downtime and headaches. It’s always a better strategy to pick a platform that can handle your business's growth from the get-go to avoid this kind of disruption down the road.

Choosing a platform is a long-term commitment. Think about where your business will be in three to five years and select a solution that has the features and scalability to grow with you.

Is a Marketplace Better Than My Own Website?

This really comes down to what you want to achieve. Selling on a huge marketplace like Amazon or Etsy is a fantastic way to get in front of a massive, ready-made audience. It’s perfect for getting those first sales and seeing if your products have real demand.

However, having your own website gives you total control over your brand, lets you build direct relationships with your customers, and usually means better profit margins. It's how you build a sustainable, independent business for the long haul. Many of the most successful sellers do both—they use marketplaces for reach while building their own site as their primary brand hub. As you set up your own channels, it's important to know how data is handled; you can review our detailed information on user privacy and data protection.

Ready to build and scale your online business with ease? Ecommerce provides AI-powered tools, automated fulfillment, and access to vetted suppliers to help you succeed. Start for free on ecommerce.co and see how simple selling online can be.

Article created using Outrank